When it comes to the concert experience, it’s impossible for anyone inside the business to go through the process with new patron empathy. Everything from buying tickets online to the in-person event are designed by people with varying degrees of experience with the process.
Granted, I’ve been focusing on these questions as they apply to the online process and much of that time is spent helping clients get past their own experience blinders.
Fortunately, a colleague turned me onto a Twitter thread from User Experience (UX) designer Andy Budd that goes a long way toward explaining the challenges that derail good user experience. Budd starts off by describing the increasingly common, and frustrating website experience:
A typical website visit in 2022
1. Figure out how to decline all but essential cookies
2. Close the support widget asking if I need help
3. Stop the auto-playing video
4. Close the “subscribe to our newsletter” pop-up
5. Try and remember why I came here in the first place— Andy Budd (@andybudd) January 2, 2022
As people have rightly said, this also often comes with…
6. A browser message asking if you’ll accept push notifications
7. Another asking if you’re willing to share your location
8. A banner suggesting you download the iPhone app
9. An NPS survey asking you to rate the site.— Andy Budd (@andybudd) January 3, 2022
And since Budd’s thread is more than professional venting, he goes on to illustrate why website UX ends up in such poor shape, even when organizations go through the process with the best of intentions.
A lot of people are rightly annoyed by the poor UX of modern websites, and are asking themselves why this happens?
The answers are disappointingly simple…
— Andy Budd (@andybudd) January 4, 2022
1) Most digital teams don't experience the website as new users experience it. They're either looking at mock-ups / sandboxed version or have already accepted all the cookies.
2) Different teams are responsible for different elements based on driving different KPIs
— Andy Budd (@andybudd) January 4, 2022
The ironic thing is that in most companies the Head of User Experience doesn't actually "own" the user experience and can't say no to these things. Instead the website becomes a battleground between sales, marketing, product and tech.
— Andy Budd (@andybudd) January 4, 2022
The final tweet in that thread is where I encounter good processes going off the rails most often. Each orchestra admin department looks at their website as a zero-sum environment where devo and marketing must fight to the figurative death for real estate. Worse, one side attempts to leverage complete control over the other via some Machiavellian power grab.
The good news is that’s not the way things need to work.
For the orchestra business, a lot of this anxiety comes from an outdated understanding of the way your patrons and ticket buyers use your websites. So instead of focusing on fighting for old school “above the fold” exposure on the home page, I work with departmental stakeholders to learn more about how they drive traffic to the site and analyze previous campaigns to quantify results.
Working with accurate data and focusing more on the user journey to conversion can go a long way toward creating far more effective UX because all parties begin to discover which pages have actual vs. perceived value.
In the end, you’ll discover you don’t even need all of the pop-ups and nags that ultimately drive more website visitors away than not.