TAFTO 2011 Contribution: Sean Hickey

Sean Hickey is no stranger to Adaptistration’s regular readers. He’s been a guest author on a few occasions and always manages to make you think about something from a different point of view. His TAFTO contribution is no different plus it introduces a term I’m trying to work into my vocabulary as much as possible: “museumification.” ~ Drew McManus

Like others who have contributed to TAFTO in the past, when I look down my long list of friends, acquaintances and contacts, it strikes me that I don’t know too many people that aren’t musicians. Nearly everyone in my life is involved in music in some way, with a great number of people working as composers, performers, producers, engineers, administrators and critics. If the purpose of TAFTO is to invite someone who doesn’t normally attend live concert events to a concert event, then I’m fortunate that even several of my musician colleagues fit that bill all too well. I can think of several people whose opinion on musical matters I value highly who simply don’t attend concerts – be they orchestra, opera, recital – with any regularity or at all. Though I certainly welcome all of the opportunities to experience live music New York has to offer, I can go for long periods without attending concerts, citing the responsibilities of family, work, exercise and my own music as reasons why I just can’t go hear the Philharmonic next week.

Lincoln Center

I’m fortunate to be offered last-minute tickets for concert events regularly and I’m often in need of a companion. Alas, it can be hard to find someone so I often attend concerts at Lincoln Center, Carnegie Hall and elsewhere alone. There are many people who rail against the museumification of classical music, that if it is to thrive and develop, then it must be taken out of the staid concert halls of the world, most of them teeming with wealthy white people of a certain age. I empathize with the sentiment as a composer, and I’m extremely encouraged by all of the alternative spaces to experience classical music – yes, orchestral music too – in places that weren’t presenting programs just a few years ago.

But I’m also one that happens to like the ritual of the concert hall experience: the crowded seats, the need to sit upright, the quiet before the downbeat, the movement of the bows. The ritual, which is clearly uncomfortable for many judging by the wheezing coughs between movements, is one where I feel I can connect with music without distraction. And unlike my cozy home, I find I can actually sit still for long periods and experience deep listening.

That sounds a bit newagey I know, but I think concert listening is one of the few things that is both communal and solitary. As an outgoing introvert, it appeals to me.

As a composer, I’m regularly recruiting friends and family to attend concerts of my music. Like many others I know, I’m disheartened by the fact that concerts of new music – or those whose programs contain some new music – are attended by a proscribed new music coterie, at least in New York, which namely consists of other composers. Though it’s always a pleasure to run into old friends and fellow supportive musicians, the need of expanding audiences is – and should be – central to any composer’s business. Fortunately, I have a small handful of non-musician friends who attend concerts of my work.

I must cite my good friend Mary Beth. Though she married a folk musician, she herself plays nothing but has omnivorous musical tastes. She and I can wax lengthily on obscure punk rock and postpunk until the bartender yawns and flicks on the lights. I gained a whole new respect for her after she invited me to a punk show in a dark Brooklyn club last year, the reasons why I was the only one willing becoming clear to me when the band took the stage. The first teeth-throttling chord hadn’t finished sounding when an elbow flew up into my eye and sent me flying. Mary Beth stayed in the very middle of the moshpit – managing to keep a deathgrip on a beer, purse and the edge of the stage – for a full hour. Needless to say, she’s not a typical orchestra patron though she would enjoy the experience and have a lot to say. In fact, among all my friends, musician or otherwise, she is one of the few that actively engages me in discussion of my music and can recall details days and weeks after attending a performance of my works. I want to include her whenever I have a performance or when those last-minute orchestra tickets come up.

Since I have several friends active in music, the main reason they don’t attend more orchestral concerts is that new music still figures into so few programs. Scanning the listings of a couple of major orchestras in my part of the world, it’s appalling to find more programs still of Beethoven and Brahms. I don’t question the greatness of the music for a moment, but if orchestras are looking to build audiences, a little new music – not just an early 20th-century piece by a dead European male – couldn’t hurt.

Of course, orchestra management would argue the reverse: that new music keeps the crowds away. To that I would say, how about programming lesser-known works by the masters or exploring some of the byways of centuries past? A performance of the works of Ries – to use but one example – puts Beethoven in better perspective. There’s not enough room here to list the excellent works never programmed by American orchestras but which find their way onto European orchestra programs. And there’s no shortage of great new music for orchestra. Just ask the patrons of the Cabrillo Festival.

When I was 15, my parents and I traveled to Chicago via train (how quaint!) from suburban Detroit. Though weaned on rock and playing the electric guitar for three years, I couldn’t have been prepared for the life-changing event of experiencing the awesome sound of the Chicago Symphony Orchestra under George Solti. On the program was Stravinsky’s Symphonies of Wind Instruments, to this day one of my favorite pieces. The sight of a stage only one-third full and absent strings, was a bizarre one that stays with me years later. More bizarre was the blocky, amelodic piece that created an overwhelming impression in its sonorities, its strange formlessness and lack of development, a musical block of clay. Somewhere around intermission I became a composer.

Though I may have some difficulty finding a friend to accompany me to the concert hall all these years later, I’m more than grateful for my parents who took their son to the orchestra and which inadvertently led me to a life in music.

~ Sean Hickey

You can also visit today’s contribution at the TAFTO resource site.

About Sean Hickey

Born in Detroit, Michigan in 1970, Sean Hickey’s earliest music education began at age 12 with an electric guitar, a Peavey amp, and a stack of Van Halen records, the early ones of course. He studied jazz guitar at Oakland University, later graduating with a degree in composition and theory from Wayne State University. His primary instructors were James Hartway, James Lentini and Leslie Bassett. Several of his recording and concert reviews may be found in the pages of the New Music Connoisseur, 21st Century Music, Modern Dance and numerous other publications. He is also a principal contributor to the Omnibus Guide to Classical Music on CD, has contributed liner notes to dozens of classical recordings and is a voting member of the National Academy of Recording Arts and Sciences. His travel and adventure pieces have appeared in Transitions Abroad, the Burlington Free Press, Trailworks, Trailsource, Orlando Weekly, ITN, Babylon Travel and elsewhere. Otra Dia, a travelogue of the writer’s travels in Peru, was published by Cantabile Press. He also lectures extensively on career options and marketing strategy for composers.

Related Posts

  • Yesterday's post referencing the Take A Friend To The Orchestra program ended up inspiring me to take a spin through some of my favorite…

  • If you haven't been to Adaptistration Jobs lately, you're missing out on a flood of new listings; in fact, there are ten new listings…

    Adaptistration Jobs
  • A few months ago, I made a big switch from using traditional comments to a system powered by Facebook. At the time, I mentioned…


0 thoughts on “TAFTO 2011 Contribution: Sean Hickey”

  1. Musicians often instinctively link the reasons why they and the public don’t attend concerts. The common deficit may be lackluster concert experiences, but I’m confident the two groups have different complaints.

    Unlike a chamber music series, a period group or new music ensemble whose mission and audience is specialized; an orchestra’s obligation is to serve its city. The halls we play in are city landmarks with thousands of seats to fill. I believe the orchestra’s mandate is to push further into the mainstream. I don’t believe this can be achieved by catering more to the musician class.

    Like the musicians referred to in this post, I attend concerts primarily out of professional curiosity. I think this is a perfectly reasonable response. But our motivations are an ineffective tool for measuring an audience’s experience.

  2. Some of the most successful and balanced programming I have experienced contains a combination of core repertoire followed by a more contemporary piece. This keeps the attention of the loyal crowd, while also piquing the interest of younger people. Being one of those younger people, I have seen a deeper interest of non-musicians in attending these types of concerts. I have been pleasantly surprised by the reaction of fellow peers and classmates, at the invitation to a symphony concert. Personally, it is always a treat to experience a piece live first, and listen to the recording afterwards. The core repertoire is enjoyable as well, bringing me back to the days (not too long ago!) when I studied such composers.

  3. A really excellent observation, Rob. I can only speak from my experience as one who has never played in an orchestra but who has worked with them for years as a composer and administrator. Serving the community at large, especially a sizable one, is a huge task for any presenter or arts institution and one must be sensitive at finding ways to please as many people as possible. The musician class alone cannot sustain any orchestra, or so I think.

  4. Sean,

    I agree that the task of filling seats and pleasing diverse audiences is a difficult and unenviable task. But I’m unconvinced that the orchestra business has yet to really try. Often we measure our success by the artistic inclinations of a few or simply by keeping the lights on. That yardstick works for small ensembles with relatively few obligations, but it’s misplaced for orchestras. In most cities (not NYC) the local orchestra is the main presenter of classical music and the largest employer of classical musicians. Without them, the boutique ensembles doing the more specialized work are just not possible. In my experience the line between the orchestra as big budget civic institution and orchestra as niche ensemble gets too easily blurred.

Leave a Comment